| IEC Fusion |
Although most funding of fusion research has been focused on tokamak and laser implosion devices, new developments in IEC (inertial electrostatic confinement) fusion using quasi-spherical magnetic fields may offer an important breakthrough.
The following document presents Dr. Robert Bussard's IEC fusion research at EMC2 over the past 17 years, as given at a Google Tech Talk lecture.
- "Should Google Go Nuclear?", November 9, 2006, 1.5 MB (revised December 26, 2008)
Dr. Bussard also gave this talk at Yahoo! on April 10, 2007. It is similar to the Google talk, except he spoke more about the impact on the world towards the end of the talk. A video of this talk is only available internally to Yahoo! employees.
The paper mentioned in the above video and article that describes his research in more detail can be found at:
- "The Advent of Clean Nuclear Fusion: Super-performance Space Power and Propulsion", Robert W. Bussard, Ph.D., 57th International Astronautical Congress, October 2-6, 2006
- "Inherent Characteristics of Fusion Power Systems: Physics, Engineering, and Economics," Robert W. Bussard and Nicholas A. Krall, December 1994, Fusion Technology, Vol. 26, pp. 1326-1336. (minor updates, November 2008)
- "Review Article: Magnetic Electrostatic Plasma Confinement,” Thomas J. Dolan, Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 36 (1994), pp. 1539-1593, doi:10.1088/0741-3335/36/10/001
Robert Bussard summarized the results and conclusions of the WB-6 program:
- "Polywell Program Results and Final Conclusions,” Robert W. Bussard, EMC2, December 2, 2006 (reformatted May 20, 2009)
IEC Fusion Physics
Detailed physics of IEC fusion are detailed in the following papers. These articles were reformatted and updated in July and August 2007 with color pdf illustrations:
- "Some Physics Considerations of Magnetic Inertial Electrostatic Confinement: A New Concept for Spherical Converging Flow Fusion," Robert W. Bussard, March 1991, Fusion Technology, Volume 19 (revised December 2008)
- "The Polywell: A Spherically Convergent Ion Focus Concept," by Nicholas Krall, Fusion Technology, Volume 22, August 1992. (minor updates, December 2008)
- "Forming and Maintaining a Potential Well in a Quasispherical Magnetic Trap," by Nicholas Krall, Michael Coleman, K. Mafei, John Lovberg, R. Jacobsen, and Robert Bussard, Physics of Plasma 2 (1), January 1995 (minor updates, December 2008)
IEC Fusion and Spaceflight
Dr. Bussard has written several papers concerning the usage of IEC fusion in space flight. These articles were updated in May-August 2007 by reformatting and adding color pdf illustrations:- "Fusion as Electric Propulsion," R.W. Bussard, Journal of Propulsion, v 6, n 5, September-October 1990, pp. 567-574. (minor updates, December 2008)
- "Inertial-Electrostatic-Fusion Propulsion Spectrum: Air-Breathing to Interstellar Flight," Robert W. Bussard and Lorin W. Jamesson, 1993, Journal of Propulsion and Power, Vol. 11, No. 2, pp. 365-372. (minor updates, December 2008)
- "The QED Engine System: Direct-Electric Fusion-Powered Rocket Propulsion Systems," Robert W. Bussard, Tenth Symposium on Space Nuclear Power and Propulsion, January 20, 1993, V.271, pp 1601-1612. (minor updates, December 2008)
- "Fusion-Electric Propulsion for Hypersonic Flight," by H.D. Froning, Jr. and Robert W. Bussard, June 28-30, 1993, AIAA/SAE/ASME/ASEE 29th Joint Propulsion Conference, Monterey, CA, AIAA 93-2611,
- "The QED Engine: Fusion-Electric Propulsion for Cis-Oort/Quasi-Interstellar (QIS) Flight," 44th Congress of the International Astronautical Federation, October 16-22, 1993. (minor updates, December 2008)
- "Design Considerations for Clean QED Fusion Propulsion Systems," by Robert W. Bussard and Lorin W. Jameson, 11th Symposium on Space Nuclear Power and Propulsion, Albuquerque, 9-13 January 1994. (revised December 2008)
- "From SSSTO to Saturn's Moon: Superperformance Fusion Propulsion for Practical Spaceflight," by Robert W. Bussard and Lorin W. Jameson, 30th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference, June 27-29, 1994, AIAA 94-3269
- "System Technical and Economic Features of QED-Engine Drive Space Transportation," Robert W. Bussard, 33rd AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference, July 6-9, 1997, Seattle, WA — AIAA 97-3071.
- "Aneutronic Fusion Propulsion for Earth-to-Orbit and Beyond," H. David Froning, Jr. and Robert W. Bussard, Space Technology and Applications International Forum, January 15, 1998, pg. 1289-1294
- "System/Subsystem Engineering Interface Considerations and R&D Requirements for IEF/QED Engine Systems," Robert W. Bussard and H. David Froning, Jr., Space Technology and Applications International Forum, January 15, 1998, pg. 1344-1351.
- "An Advanced Fusion Energy System for Outer-Planet Space Propulsion," Robert W. Bussard, January 14, 2002, Space Technology and Applications International Forum, Volume 608.
IEC Fusion Publicity
Mention of IEC fusion research was made in the following articles:
- "Practical Fusion, or Just a Bubble?", Kenneth Chang, New York Times, February 27, 2007
- "Fighting for Fusion - Why the U.S. Isn't Funding a Promising Energy Technology," March 5, 2007, William Matthews, DefenseNews.com
- "Ramjet designer's new pitch: safe, cheap, fusion reactor," June 4, 2007, Colin Johnson, EE Times
- “Fusion — Elegant Simplicity,” May 3, 2007, Barry Ashby, Industrial Heating (editorial)
- “Fusion Quest Goes Forward,” June 12, 2008, Alan Boyle, MSNBC Cosmic Log
- “Fusion We Can Believe In?” December 16, 2008, Alan Boyle, MSNBC Cosmic Log
- “Dr. Richard Nebel Interview,” by Sander Olson; Nexbigfuture, with additional talk-polywell commentary, May 5, 2009
- “Fusion Goes Forward From the Fringe,” May 10, 2011, Alan Boyle, MSNBC Cosmic Log
Energy/Matter Conversion Corporation Inertial-Electrodynamic Fusion (IEF) Device was the winner of the 2006 Outstanding Technology of the Year Award by the International Academy of Science
Two sites with additional information on IEC fusion have been provided by Joe Strout at:
Information on EMC2 Fusion Development Corporation, a charitable research and development organization with a focus on fusion can be found at:
In April 2007, Dr. Robert Bussard, stated that due to the publicity from his 11/9/2006 talk at Google and the 2006 Outstanding Technology of the Year Award, the U.S. Navy sent him a contract extension at no cost. There was no funding attached to it at that time. Subsequently, on August 21, 2007, EMC2 received DOD funding for its Phase I research in Albuquerque, NM to construct the WB-7 and WB-8 machines, to validate the WB-6 results.
EMC2 Reports
Energy/Matter Conversion Corporation reports from 1990 and 1991 relating to aspects of IEC Fusion are:- Bussard, Robert W., Nicholas, Krall A., "Electron Leakage Through Magnetic Cusps in the Polywell Confinement Geometry," 1991, EMC2-0191-02
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., "Electron Transit Time in Central Virtual Anode Wells," 1991, EMC2-0291-03
- Bussard, Robert W., “Fusion Lifetime Limits on Ion Upscattering,” 1991, EMC2-0291-04
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., "Electron Recirculation in Electrostatic Multicusp Systems: I-Confinement and Losses in Simple Power Law Wells," 1991, EMC2-0491-03
- Bussard, Robert W.,“Effective Gyro Hole Loss Radius and Diamagnetic Limit in Polywell Systems,” 1991, EMC2-0591-02
- Bussard, Robert W."Ion and Electron Flow and Some Critical Radii in Polywell Sysetms," 1991, EMC2-0791-02
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., "EKXL: A Dynamic Poisson-Solver for Polywell/HEPS Spherical Converging Flow Systems," 1991, EMC2-0791-03
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., “Electron Recirculation in Electrostatic Multicusp Systems," 1991, Report EMC2-0791-04
- Bussard, Robert W.,“Collisional Equilibration,” 1990, EMC2-0890-03
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., "Electron Current, Beta Limit Line Operation and Power Balance in WB Mode," 1991, EMC2-0891-02
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., "SCIF e-Guns, Ion Inputs and Controlled Operation," 1991, EMC2-0891-03
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., “Bremsstrahlung and Synchrotron Radiation Losses in Polywell Systems,” 1991, EMC2-1291-02
- Bussard, Robert W.,“Core Collisional Ion Upscattering and Loss Time,” February 1991, EMC2-1090-03
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., "Phenomenological Modeling of Polywell/SCIF Multi-Cusp Inertial-Electrostatic Confinement Systems," 1991, EMC2-1191-02
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., “Bremmstrahlung Radiation Losses in Polywell Systems,” 1991, EMC2-0891-04
- Bussard, Robert W.; “Inertial-Electrostatic-Fusion: A Promising New Power Concept, “17 April 1993, EMC2-0493-04 (Updated November 2008)
- Bussard, Robert W.; “Neutron Capture, Structure Damage, and Economics of Various Nuclear Sources,” 29 March 1993, EMC-0393-04 (Updated November 2008)
- Bussard, Robert W.; “Magnetic Field Energy in Pokywell IEC Systems,”, June 1992, EMC2-0692-03 (Updated November 2008)
- “Preliminary Study of Inertial-Electrostatic-Fusion (IEF) for Electric Power Plants,” EPRI TR-103394s, February 1994 (Updated November 2008)
- EMC2 Inertial-Electrostatic Fusion (IEF) Development: Final Successful Tests of WB-6; October/November 2005, Robert W. Bussard and R. Michael Wray, EMC2-0806-04, August 4, 2006.
EMC2 Reports (reformatted)
The following Energy/Matter Conversion Corporation reports have been reformatted:- Bussard, Robert W., Nicholas, Krall A., "Electron Leakage Through Magnetic Cusps in the Polywell Confinement Geometry," 1991, EMC2-0191-02 (Reformatted July 2009)
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., "Electron Transit Time in Central Virtual Anode Wells," 1991, EMC2-0291-03 (Reformatted July 2009)
- Bussard, Robert W., “Fusion Lifetime Limits on Ion Upscattering,” 1991, EMC2-0291-04
- Bussard, Robert W.; “Inertial-Electrostatic-Fusion: A Promising New Power Concept, “17 April 1993, EMC2-0493-04 (Updated November 2008)
- Bussard, Robert W.; “Neutron Capture, Structure Damage, and Economics of Various Nuclear Sources,” 29 March 1993, EMC-0393-04 (Updated November 2008)
- Bussard, Robert W.,“Effective Gyro Hole Loss Radius and Diamagnetic Limit in Polywell Systems,” 1991, EMC2-0591-02 (Reformatted July 2009)
- Bussard, Robert W.; “Magnetic Field Energy in Polywell IEC Systems,” June 1992, EMC2-0692-03 (Updated November 2008)
- Bussard, Robert W."Ion and Electron Flow and Some Critical Radii in Polywell Sysetms," 1991, EMC2-0791-02 (Reformatted July 2009)
- "Waste Transmutation by High Flux DT Fusion Neutrons from Inertial-Electrostatic Fusion (IEF) Systems,” Robert W. Bussard; Global 1993 International Conference and Technology Exhibition on Future Nuclear Systems: Emerging Fuel Cycles and Waste Disposal Options, September 12-17, 1993; Sheraton Hotel, Seattle, WA; EMC2-0693-03
- Bussard, Robert W.,“Collisional Equilibration,” 1990, EMC2-0890-03 (Reformatted July 2009)
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., “Bremmstrahlung Radiation Losses in Polywell Systems,” 1991, EMC2-0891-04 (Reformatted June 2009)
- Bussard, Robert W.,“Core Collisional Ion Upscattering and Loss Time,” February 1991, EMC2-1090-03 (Reformatted July 2009)
- Bussard, Robert W., King, Katherine E., “Bremsstrahlung and Synchrotron Radiation Losses in Polywell Systems,” 1991, EMC2-1291-02 (Reformatted July 2009)
- “Preliminary Study of Inertial-Electrostatic-Fusion (IEF) for Electric Power Plants,” EPRI TR-103394s, February 1994 (Updated November 2008)
EMC2 Patents
Dr. Bussard’s last patent application:- “Method and Apparatus for Controlling Charged Particles”, by Robert W. Bussard, August 7, 2008; US Patent Application 2008/0187086, (12.5 MB)
Tom Ligon Articles
Tom Ligon has written numerous articles and presentations on IEC fusion and its applications:- "Inertial Electrostatic Fusion — Is this the Answer to Interplanetary Space Travel?", Tom Ligon, 26th International Space Development Conference, Dallas, TX, May 25-28, 2007 (presentation)
- "Inertial Electrodynamic Fusion and the Internal Combustion Engine," by Tom Ligon, June 17, 2007
- "El Dorado," by Tom Ligon, Analog Science Fiction and Fact, October 2007, pg. 84. (novelette)
- "The World's Simplest Fusion Reactor Revisited or The Not-Quite-So-Simple Fusion Reactor, and How They Made it Work," Tom Ligon, Analog Science Fiction and Fact, January/February 2008
- "Questions and Answers with Thomas Ligon on the Polywell," by the Polywell Blog, http://thepolywellblog.blogspot.com/, October 20, 2009
- “Thomas Ligon Polywell 21 Janaury 2009 Interview,” transcript by Matt Moynihan on April 29, 2010
Polywell Blog Posts
John Smith has asked that we post the following Polywell blog posts:- Possibilities, December 10, 2011—markets for Polywell
- The Startup, February 2, 2012—suggestions for a venture capital pitch
- Green Sun, July 12, 2012—review of Charles Grey’s book, A Green Sun
- Polywell Physics, July 30, 2012—how the WB6 works
- How It Works, September 10, 2012—how Polywell fusion works, with citations
“Current” Status
As of September 2009, EMC2 was awarded a $7,855,504 cost-plus-fixed-fee contract for research, analysis, development, and testing for a WB-8 machine. It is funded by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) of 2009 as a Research, Development, Test and Evaluation plan. The magnetic electron containment coils of WB-8 will be redesigned to minimize electron loss and maximize plasma confinement. WB-6 and WB-7 were operated at a pulsed magnetic field strength of 0.1 Tesla. WB-8 will be operated at a pulsed magnetic field strength of 0.8 Tesla.As part of the contract, a predictive computational model of the WB behavior for detailed two-dimensional and three-dimensional profile predictions of its plasma density, ion energy and magnetic field structure will be provided.
An optional WB8.1 machine may be developed for an additional $4,455,077. It would have higher ion drive capabilities, with the intent of demonstrating a pB11 reaction. (The ion drive system will be able to inject either ionized hydrogen or ionized boron 11.)
A second objective is to demonstrate improved confinement, ion energy, and fusion reactivity; as well as to update the previously developed computational model.
While EMC2 owns the commercialization rights for the Polywell, as of March 2010, it cannot do this with its DOD funding. Contributions to the New Mexico Community Foundation website will enable:
- Designing an attractive commercial reactor package.
- Identify the high leverage physics items that most impact the design (i.e. how good is good enough).
- Provides a base design when we are ready to proceed to the next step.
- Polywell Results and Final Conclusions, @December 2012
- High Energy Electron Confinement in a Magnetic Cusp Configuration, Jaeyoung Park, Nicholas Krall, Paul Sieck, Dustin Offermann, Michael Skillicorn, Andew Sanchez, Kevin Davis, Eric Alderson, and Giovanni Lapenta, June 1, 2014
- Low-Cost Fusion Project Steps Out of the Shadows and Looks for Money, by Alan Boyle, NBC Science News, June 13, 2014
IEC 2009
The 11th United States - Japan workshop on Inertial Electrostatic Confinement Fusion was held October 12-13, 2009 in Madison, WI at the University of Wisconsin Fusion Technology Institute. The conference papers can be found at:Related Fusion Articles
Papers that are frequently cited in the above references include:- "’Venetian Blind’ Direct Energy Conversion for Fusion Reactors, Ralph W. Moir, William L Barr; Nuclear Fusion 13, January 1973
- “Solar System Spaceships,” Thrust Into Space, Chapter 5; by Maxwell Hunter, 1966, Holt, Rhinehard and Winston, New York
A paper on the application of neutrons generated from an IEF fusion source to treat radioactive waste:
- "Waste Transmutation by High Flux DT Fusion Neutrons from Inertial-Electrostatic Fusion (IEF) Systems,” Robert W. Bussard; Global 1993 International Conference and Technology Exhibition on Future Nuclear Systems: Emerging Fuel Cycles and Waste Disposal Options, September 12-17, 1993; Sheraton Hotel, Seattle, WA; EMC2-0693-03
On September 4, 2009; Dolly H Gray, executor for the Robert W. Bussard Estate, provided permission to republish his papers that had been reformatted and provided with color illustrations and updated references on this site.